| 1913 – Julius Pollock Fairmont Field Club |
1952 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1991 – Harold Payne The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1914 – Julius Pollock Parkersburg Country Club |
1953 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1992 – Eric Shaffer The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1915 – Julius Pollock Wheeling Country Club |
1954 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1993 – Harold Payne The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1916 – George Hewitt The Greenbrier Resort |
1955 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
1994 – Steve Fox The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1917 – No Tournament – WWI | 1956 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1995 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1918 – Forrest McNeill Wheeling |
1957 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
1996 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1919 – Julius Pollock The Greenbrier Resort |
1958 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1997 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1920 – Forrest McNeill The Greenbrier Resort |
1959 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
1998 – Pat Carter Pete Dye Golf Club |
| 1921 – Julius Pollock The Greenbrier Resort |
1960 – Ed Tutwiler Guyan Golf & Country Club |
1999 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1922 – Julius Pollock The Homestead |
1961 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
2000 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1923 – Densmore Shute The Greenbrier Resort |
1962 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2001 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1924 – Julius Pollock The Greenbrier |
1963 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
2002 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1925 – Densmore Shute The Greenbrier Resort |
1964 – Jim Ward The Greenbrier Resort |
2003 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1926 – Forrest McNeill The Greenbrier Resort |
1965 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2004 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1927 – Dan Rownd The Greenbrier Resort |
1966 – Barney Thompson The Greenbrier Resort |
2005 – Tim Fisher The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1928 – Julius Pollock The Greenbrier Resort |
1967 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2006 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1929 – Ira Rodgers The Greenbrier Resort |
1968 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2007 – Anthony Reale The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1930 – Palmer Stacy The Greenbrier Resort |
1969 – Barney Thompson The Greenbrier Resort |
2008 – Tim Fisher The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1931 – Julius Pollock The Greenbrier Resort |
1970 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2009 – Tim Fisher The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1932 – Fred Bannerot The Greenbrier Resort |
1971 – Barney Thompson The Greenbrier Resort |
2010 – Jonathan Bartlett The Greenbrier |
| 1933 – Fred Bannerot The Greenbrier Resort |
1972 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2011 – Christian Brand The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1934 – Tom Bloch The Greenbrier Resort |
1973 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2012 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1935 – Tom Brand The Greenbrier Resort |
1974 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2013 – Sam O’Dell The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1936 – Tom Brand The Greenbrier Resort |
1975 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
2014 – Brian Anania The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1937 – Tom Brand The Greenbrier Resort |
1976 – Jay Guthrie The Greenbrier Resort |
2015 – Sam O’Dell The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1938 – Frank Crum The Greenbrier Resort |
1977 – Jay Guthrie The Greenbrier Resort |
2016 – Alan Cooke The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1939 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1978 – Scott Davis The Greenbrier Resort |
2017 – Sam O’Dell The Resort at Glade Springs |
| 1940 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1979 – Harold Payne The Greenbrier Resort |
2018– Sam O’Dell The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1941 – Fred Bannerot The Greenbrier Resort |
1980 – Ken Frye The Greenbrier Resort |
2019– Mason Williams The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1942 – No Tournament – WWII | 1981 – Mike Owens The Greenbrier Resort |
2020- Alex Easthom The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1943 – No Tournament – WWII | 1982 – Greg Meade The Greenbrier Resort |
2021 – Philip Reale The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1944 – No Tournament – WWII | 1983 – Danny Warren The Greenbrier Resort |
2022 – Noah Mullens The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1945 – No Tournament – WWII | 1984 – Scott Gilmore The Greenbrier Resort |
2023 – Cameron Jarvis The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1946 – No Tournament – WWII | 1985 – Danny Warren The Greenbrier Resort |
2024 – Christian Brand The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1947 – No Tournament – WWII | 1986 – Harold Payne The Greenbrier Resort |
2025 – ??? The Greenbrier Resort |
| 1948 – Ed Tutwiler The Greenbrier Resort |
1987 – Harold Payne The Greenbrier Resort |
|
| 1949 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
1988 – Steve Fox The Greenbrier Resort |
|
| 1950 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
1989 – Pat Carter The Greenbrier Resort |
|
| 1951 – Bill Campbell The Greenbrier Resort |
1990 – Scott Gilmore The Greenbrier Resort |